Lithium battery - worth the expense?

TinBoats.net

Help Support TinBoats.net:

Buster

Member
Joined
Sep 16, 2020
Messages
19
Reaction score
28
Location
Minneapolis, MN
About 15 years ago I worked on a medical device powered by lithium batteries, so I had to deep dive into the technology as part of product design and regulatory approval. The charging information of different cells was, as Ray Clark says, all over the place, but storage at full charge was never desirable. Storing for long periods at full charge will damage the cells. If you have a newer phone, computer or other device, you may notice they don't fully charge right away if you plug them in over night. They'll charge to 75-85% and then stop, giving a final boost to full charge around the time you normally start using them in the morning. The laptop I'm writing this on is almost always plugged in and as such holds its charge at 80%. If I need a full charge for a day or two off the charger, I have to tell it to fully charge. Likewise, if I wake up at 3AM my phone won't be fully charged, even if I dropped it on the charger many hours ago. But at 5AM when I normally pick it up it's charged to full. Whether 30%, 50%, or 85%, anything below full charge is better. As CRS says, the voltage check for lithium isn't reliable without highly sophisticated circuitry, so the MinnKota press to check feature is pretty worthless. That's a feature of the discharge curve, which for lithium is very flat (compared to lead acid which has a steady and easily monitored decline.) Monitoring Ah used is the far superior way, thus something like a SmartShunt or similar battery monitor (I mention SmartShunt only because I use one and can vouch for it--I'm sure others are good.) If I fish a few hours twice a week, I leave the batteries in whatever state of charge they were in after fishing, unless they're below about 40%. Then I plug in the night before I head out.
Another thing to watch is charge rate. Generally, lower charge rates are better, but of course that sucks if you've used 50Ah and want to charge overnight with a 3A charger. 1/20th to 1/10th C is a good range, but don't worry about anything under 1/2C (That's a ratio of charge rate over total capacity, so a 5A charger on a 100Ah battery is 1/20C. A 10A charger on a 20Ah battery is 1/2C, and so on.)
With good quality modern batteries, the degradation from "abuse" is not fast. Don't get overly concerned if you charge to full today expecting to go out tomorrow and then work or weather keeps you off the water for a week. But it is worth worrying about when storing a battery over the winter, or even if you're a Saturday fisherman and always charge to full after use. Charging the night before use would be better.
Unlike a cell phone, you probably aren't charging every day, 365 days a year. So if you abuse the snot out of your trolling battery and only get 600 cycles out of it instead of 1000, that's still decades of use for a weekend fisherman in Minnesota getting out 20 times a year, but it cuts my cell phone from about 3 years to 2 years. So it's relative. You don't have to be overly concerned. If you're the kinda person that geeks out about this stuff, a good battery monitor is helpful. I you don't care, do the best you can and the battery will still likely outlive your boat ownership until you sell it for something better or something cheaper, depending on your needs.
 

onthewater102

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 15, 2014
Messages
2,266
Reaction score
2
Location
CT
Chargers designed for handling lithium batteries are a must. Finagling a lead acid charger to charge a lithium battery is where the fires come from.
 

Steph Boeker

Well-known member
TinBoats Supporter
Joined
Apr 7, 2023
Messages
132
Reaction score
99
About 15 years ago I worked on a medical device powered by lithium batteries, so I had to deep dive into the technology as part of product design and regulatory approval. The charging information of different cells was, as Ray Clark says, all over the place, but storage at full charge was never desirable. Storing for long periods at full charge will damage the cells. If you have a newer phone, computer or other device, you may notice they don't fully charge right away if you plug them in over night. They'll charge to 75-85% and then stop, giving a final boost to full charge around the time you normally start using them in the morning. The laptop I'm writing this on is almost always plugged in and as such holds its charge at 80%. If I need a full charge for a day or two off the charger, I have to tell it to fully charge. Likewise, if I wake up at 3AM my phone won't be fully charged, even if I dropped it on the charger many hours ago. But at 5AM when I normally pick it up it's charged to full. Whether 30%, 50%, or 85%, anything below full charge is better. As CRS says, the voltage check for lithium isn't reliable without highly sophisticated circuitry, so the MinnKota press to check feature is pretty worthless. That's a feature of the discharge curve, which for lithium is very flat (compared to lead acid which has a steady and easily monitored decline.) Monitoring Ah used is the far superior way, thus something like a SmartShunt or similar battery monitor (I mention SmartShunt only because I use one and can vouch for it--I'm sure others are good.) If I fish a few hours twice a week, I leave the batteries in whatever state of charge they were in after fishing, unless they're below about 40%. Then I plug in the night before I head out.
Another thing to watch is charge rate. Generally, lower charge rates are better, but of course that sucks if you've used 50Ah and want to charge overnight with a 3A charger. 1/20th to 1/10th C is a good range, but don't worry about anything under 1/2C (That's a ratio of charge rate over total capacity, so a 5A charger on a 100Ah battery is 1/20C. A 10A charger on a 20Ah battery is 1/2C, and so on.)
With good quality modern batteries, the degradation from "abuse" is not fast. Don't get overly concerned if you charge to full today expecting to go out tomorrow and then work or weather keeps you off the water for a week. But it is worth worrying about when storing a battery over the winter, or even if you're a Saturday fisherman and always charge to full after use. Charging the night before use would be better.
Unlike a cell phone, you probably aren't charging every day, 365 days a year. So if you abuse the snot out of your trolling battery and only get 600 cycles out of it instead of 1000, that's still decades of use for a weekend fisherman in Minnesota getting out 20 times a year, but it cuts my cell phone from about 3 years to 2 years. So it's relative. You don't have to be overly concerned. If you're the kinda person that geeks out about this stuff, a good battery monitor is helpful. I you don't care, do the best you can and the battery will still likely outlive your boat ownership until you sell it for something better or something cheaper, depending on your needs.
Great read, thank you for sharing.
Now, I'm not a very concise person, & unfortunately, I'm kind of slow, (simple?) but want to understand clearly, so may I ask in a more simplistic kind of way :
Are you saying for those that aren't anal about it, that : (in your experience)
a) leaving a battery shelved w/out charging isn't a big thing in the long run ? (during on off use time)
b) charging just before you geaux out is best, especially if there could be a week or two between uses ?
c) Storing for long periods of time (like months) is best at considerably less than fully charged ?
Thank for your generous consideration for my clearer understanding,
Sincerely ...................
God bless.
 

Buster

Member
Joined
Sep 16, 2020
Messages
19
Reaction score
28
Location
Minneapolis, MN
Great read, thank you for sharing.
Now, I'm not a very concise person, & unfortunately, I'm kind of slow, (simple?) but want to understand clearly, so may I ask in a more simplistic kind of way :
Are you saying for those that aren't anal about it, that : (in your experience)
a) leaving a battery shelved w/out charging isn't a big thing in the long run ? (during on off use time)
b) charging just before you geaux out is best, especially if there could be a week or two between uses ?
c) Storing for long periods of time (like months) is best at considerably less than fully charged ?
Thank for your generous consideration for my clearer understanding,
Sincerely ...................
God bless.
B and C are correct as stated. For A, I was saying that for best life, you're better off at less than full charge but what level doesn't really matter as long as it's above about 40% and below 85%. If you know you aren't depleting it it's fine (best!) to store without charging. For instance, with my 100Ah battery that I use for trolling only (got an outboard for place-to-place) I know that 3 hours on the water doesn't get it below 40-50%, so I ignore it until the night I go fishing again. If I'm fighting a wind and back trolling at full speed for 3 hrs, that's different and I'll give it an hour or two of charge when I get home. That's before I got my monitor which pretty much confirmed my guesstimates.
Ask more if you like. I wasn't quite sure what you were getting at with A so I may have missed the point.
 

airshot

Well-known member
TinBoats Supporter
Joined
Feb 18, 2009
Messages
1,184
Reaction score
700
Location
Perrysburg Ohio
LOCATION
Perrysburg Ohio
Great read, thank you for sharing.
Now, I'm not a very concise person, & unfortunately, I'm kind of slow, (simple?) but want to understand clearly, so may I ask in a more simplistic kind of way :
Are you saying for those that aren't anal about it, that : (in your experience)
a) leaving a battery shelved w/out charging isn't a big thing in the long run ? (during on off use time)
b) charging just before you geaux out is best, especially if there could be a week or two between uses ?
c) Storing for long periods of time (like months) is best at considerably less than fully charged ?
Thank for your generous consideration for my clearer understanding,
Sincerely ...................
God bless.
Just to be clear, he is refering to Lipo type batteries not lead acid or AGM type batteries!!
 

Pothole

Member
Joined
May 23, 2013
Messages
7
Reaction score
2
Location
Mt. Ulla, NC
Bought a 100 ah lithium from Lithium Hub a little over a year ago for slightly over $600 (on sale). I use it to run my lights, electronics, and my 12v Power Drive trolling motor. I have a separate wet cell battery for starting with both on a NOCO charger that can be set for whatever type battery I have. My lithium battery comes with an 11-year warranty, and I can check the remaining capacity with an app on my phone while I am on the water. I do a lot of fishing where I utilize the Spot Lock feature on my trolling motor, and I have yet to take my battery down below 50%. I'm sure in heavy current or high winds that would change, but this battery will easily last me a day of fishing without worrying about how much capacity it has left. It has definitely been a great investment and I am glad I went with a higher-grade battery than some of the cheaper lithium options out there.
 

airshot

Well-known member
TinBoats Supporter
Joined
Feb 18, 2009
Messages
1,184
Reaction score
700
Location
Perrysburg Ohio
LOCATION
Perrysburg Ohio
Bought a 100 ah lithium from Lithium Hub a little over a year ago for slightly over $600 (on sale). I use it to run my lights, electronics, and my 12v Power Drive trolling motor. I have a separate wet cell battery for starting with both on a NOCO charger that can be set for whatever type battery I have. My lithium battery comes with an 11-year warranty, and I can check the remaining capacity with an app on my phone while I am on the water. I do a lot of fishing where I utilize the Spot Lock feature on my trolling motor, and I have yet to take my battery down below 50%. I'm sure in heavy current or high winds that would change, but this battery will easily last me a day of fishing without worrying about how much capacity it has left. It has definitely been a great investment and I am glad I went with a higher-grade battery than some of the cheaper lithium options out there.
Great to hear, they are improving them all the time. When used as they are designed for, they perform quite well !! People just have to be sure to handle them correctly !!! I am doing some research on them now, so I will be ready when my current agm batteries give up..
 

thill

Well-known member
Joined
Feb 25, 2011
Messages
1,124
Reaction score
791
Location
Virginia, USA
Mostly to find anyone who uses a deep cycle Li battery and if they agree with the positives noted. I've never heard of a budget Li battery, but if it holds its charge better than lead batteries at mid-speed using the trolling motor, I might consider buying one for my light aluminum row boat. (Especially to save the back hauling it in and out of truck and boat!)

Thanks to all of you for help shooting me in the direction of a budget (?) Li.
I bought a budget LiFeP04 100AH battery on Amazon by TimeUSB for $249, and I am very happy with it:

So happy that I bought a second one. These things are awesome! I've also been using them with an inverter when camping, and WOW, they last forever! Very impressed.

As someone stated above, I'll probably never go back to lead acid batteries. 10 years from now, I'll probably still be using this pair. Now THAT is a thought worth considering.
 
Joined
Aug 9, 2023
Messages
3
Reaction score
10
LOCATION
Portage, WI
Lithium batteries was the rave in the motorcycle world. Problem is they do not work well in cold weather. A lot of folks where getting stuck with a bike that would not start. Guess it would work for fishing.
I was one of those bikers. Bought it and it died completely within 8 months here in Wisconsin. I’m sticking with lead right now for the boat as it meets my needs inexpensively. I am generally always alone so the added weight actually helps smooth out my ride.
 
Top