I always used the regular ol' Scumfrogs, and when I fish with other people that don't frog much, they often end up using them. I, on the other hand, recently switched over to a frog that I found at Fleet Farm one day that is just a plain looking green frog, but instead of the skirt like on the scumfrogs, it actually has a set of legs. This thing has consistently produced big fish for me this year, and I really believe it's because this thing really actually looks like a real frog. I would say when fishing with other people that are using the scumfrogs, I consistently get at least twice as many strikes fishing the same areas from the same boat at the same time. I have to go buy more (my last one is probably still lodged in the roof of the mouth of the biggest bass I have ever seen in real life...) so I will find out what it's called and post a pic next time I make it over to Fleet or Gander Mountain.