how good are your hand lettering skills ???
you can either paint freehand with sign painters 1-Shot lettering enamels.
or - you can cut a mask out of regular sticky back shelf paper with an X-Acto knife and spray with Rust-Oleum
or - you can visit your local sign shop and have a digital computer cut paint mask made.
and as Dale mentioned - any good quality oil gloss enamel will work. (or latex, if you want to roll that way).
If you decided to go with the adhesive back paint mask - peel the mask off as soon as the paint sets up.
this will prevent lifting around the edges. If you wait until the paint dries - you will peel up the paint with the mask.
also, the surface must be pristine and free of any contaminants and then scuffed gently with the green scotch pad.
The end result that you are looking for will dictate the method and products you use.
I myself would prefer 23k gold leaf with a 1/8" outline with a 3/4" gray drop shadow to the right.
yeah - I've done it a couple of times.
.