The problem is a brand new out of the box is under $2k all over,so your on with $1200,any higher and your out of range but hey it can't hurt to try. In reality it's a $1k-$1200 motor all day but it's what people are willing to pay. You should get at least $1k for it if it's really clean and runs well. Again,long shaft in a 9.9hp is really hard to sell but you just have to be patient. If your in no rush just throw it on for $1200 with no obo and see where u go for a month on Craigslist. Word of advice, forget ebay you will get killed on fees. Make sure you update everyday,that is the most important thing. I do one post and then,I leave 3 unopened drafts in my craigslist account so the next day I go to drafts and put up a new one. I do 3 of the same posts, by day 3 your original one will ask if you want to renew so do that every day and your post will always,be visible in the 1st couple of craigslist pages. If you do one post, by day 3 it's like 25 pages back and most people don't usually want to go back that far so keep it fresh and it will sell fast,good luck.