Here is another question then...If your buying a reel, Would a determining factor be a free spare spool?
Would you rather a cheaper reel with an option to buy a spare spool if needed?
Generally higher end reels come with a spare identical spool. A lot of times if it is a cheaper reel that has an aluminum spool, they will give you a graphite spare spool. A spare spool kinda seems like a given to me, but it is hardly a selling point. I do, however, like having a spare spool around in case my drag gets worn out, I have a new drag ready to use.
I never use spare spools, I found out the hard way the spare spool has more memory than the original spool
No offense, but I really cannot see how a spare spool could make more memory than the original. Almost always the spare spool is identical, or at most a different material, but still identical. Did you have your spare spool spooled up and stored that way? If that was the case, having your line on a spool and not using will give you tons of memory. Was the line the same? Just wondering because I have never had any problems like that with a spare spool.